Paul, attach a screenshot of what you see on the home page.
And PSX5Central is not live yet. I only made the banner because I had to make a custom banner anyway and it made zero sense to me to design a PSX4Central banner when it's only going to be up for a couple more weeks
EDIT: Never mind Paul. I was playing around with my dummy member and the settings didn't stick. Seems admins can assign the theme but the overall forum settings will over ride it. I'm sorry Paul
Usually with SMF, admins can override anything if they tell the forum to. Anyway, just hang tight.