New scores from PSM, Next Gen, and EGM!

This info is from PS2.ign forums.

PSM
Metal Gear Solid2:SOL 10/10
Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3 10/10
NHL2002 9/10
Ace Combat 4 9/10
Hlaf Life 9/10
Harvest Moon 8/10
Capcom vs SNK2 7/10



EGM:

PS2 games:
ACE COMBAT 4
•7.0
•7.0
•7.5
BATMAN VENGEANCE
•6.0
•5.0
•6.5
CAPCOM VS. SNK 2
•8.0
•7.5
•9.0
GUILTY GEAR X
•7.5
•7.0
•7.0
CRASH BANDICOOT
•5.0
•4.5
•4.0
HALF-LIFE
•8.5
•8.0
•8.0
NASCAR THUNDER 2002
•8.5
•8.5
•7.5
NHL 2002
•9.0
•9.0
•8.5
OKAGE SHADOW KING
•5.5
•5.5
•6.5
TONY HAWK 3
•9.5
•9.0
•9.5
DEVIL MAY CRY
•9.0
•8.5
•9.0


Gamecube:
Super Monkey Ball
9.0
7.0
8.5
Wave Race: Blue Storm
8.0
6.0
5.5
Luigi\'s Mansion
8.0
5.5
9.0
Rogue Squadron 2
9.0
9.0
9.0


Xbox:
MADDEN
9.0
4X4 EVOLUTION 2
3.0
5.0
5.5
CEL DAMAGE
8.5
6.5
8.0
THPS 2X
7.5
7.0
8.0
NASCAR HEAT 2002
6.5
6.5
7.0


NEXT GEN
These have been deleted because the person who posted the scores failed to prove that they were real.

-------------------
It\'s a good time to be a PS2 owner.

It seems clear that ps2 is going to own this fall.  PS2 seems to be doninating in the rating.  Mostly in NextGen.  I agree Luigi mansion and wave racer getting a 2 is pretty bad.:thepimp: :thepimp: :thepimp:

For those of you who have seen Luigi\'s Mansion, Wave Race, or Halo, do you agree with the scores?  Disagree?

Ahh.. now this is what I\'ve been waiting for.  All 3 consoles are having their games reviewed at the same time.  Finally, the taste of competition returns.

I can\'t wait to get the new PSM and check out their MGS2 review.  From the looks of things, it has lived up to the hype and then some.

It turns out that the Next Gen scores might not be real.  The guy who posted them says he will have scans posted, but he\'s been gone for quite a while.  Can we say Photoshop?  So ignore the Next Gen scores and just look at the EGM scores until we get some proof.

Here\'s the page where the Next Gen scores originated from:  http://boards.ign.com/message.asp?topic=12604023&page=4

why would you post fake reviews? that makes no sense!

Originally posted by Claypool 2001
why would you post fake reviews? that makes no sense!

Are you asking why I would post fake scores, or why he would post fake scores?  I\'ll answer both questions.  I posted those scores because I\'m an idiot.  I shouldn\'t have posted them without proof.  He posted those scores probably just to make NGC and Xbox fans scared, and to make the PS2 look superior.  The EGM and PSM scores are from a different person, and I think they have been confirmed.  It\'s too bad there isn\'t a review of DOA3.  I really wanted to see what that got.

I think thier real the same scores showed up on IGN forums

I doubt someone would fake them cause the truth would be known with in hours if not a day

Originally posted by IronFist
This info is from PS2.ign forums.

PSM
 Harvest Moon 8/10
Capcom vs SNK2 7/10

WHAT THE FU*^? Harvest Moon got higher than Capcom vs. SNK 2?!? Did they (Capcom) screw the game up or are the PSM guys not SF fans? I gotta read that review.

Thanks for the info IronFist.

Interesting scores for Ace Combat,
i really wonder if it is worth buying ...

How could Halo get a 3/5? Every single magazine and gaming site that has played it has been praising it as God\'s gift to gaming... either these are fake or the developers managed to fu*k up the final product somehow.

Then again I was sure that ZOE was going to get a 9.5 or above from IGN and somehow Konami screwed that one up... I guess anything can happen.

[color=0033CC]Well Silent Hill got a 7 when it was clearly a 9. I take game scores very lightly.[/color]