silent hill 2 or drakan: the anicent gates

hey what ps2 games should i get i was going to get oni
but some of  forums said i shouldn\'t  get because the game
control sucks,so now i am thinking of get silent hill 2 have
the first one and like very much .but i saw some awsome
screenshots of drakan  and been think getting that one
so if there anyone who thinks  i shoul get silent hill 2 or drakan2
please reply , p.s how  bad is alone in the dark game for
psone or ps2