12.4 percent?!?!? No wonder Kerry is for taxing people earning $200,000 or more - his wife has an army of lawyers and accountants to keep her taxes nice and low. Champion of the middle class?
Teresa\'s Taxes, Continued
The super-rich really are different.
Wednesday, October 20, 2004 12:01 a.m. EDT
Our Monday editorial on Teresa Heinz Kerry\'s low (12.4%) 2003 average federal tax rate has generated a huge reader response, much of it helpful in illuminating the issues. So allow us to elaborate a bit more on Mrs. Kerry\'s impressive ability to pay a smaller proportion of her income in tax than most Americans.
One point we failed to mention is that Mrs. Kerry paid only a token Social Security tax. That\'s because the payroll tax is assessed on wages, and Mrs. Kerry declared very little wage income. She gets most of her income from dividends and interest, as many wealthy people do. This is fine by us, but it is one more advantage she has over the vast majority of Americans who draw a weekly paycheck and must (with their employer) cough up the 15.3% payroll levy.
A few readers objected that we were unfair to Mrs. Kerry in noting that she avoided taxation by investing in tax-exempt bonds of various kinds, since millions of other Americans do the same. Well, we did say this is perfectly legal and we have nothing in particular against municipal bonds. Our main point is that this is one more advantage Mrs. Kerry would have over working stiffs on salary if her husband wins the White House and follows through on his plan to raise taxes.
It\'s very hard to dodge a tax increase on salary income, especially for middle-class folk who need the money. Many couples who earn more than $200,000 a year are non-wealthy Americans who happen to be at the peak of their earning years and have big bills (such as college educations) to meet now or down the road. They haven\'t had time--or been lucky enough to marry rich--to build up the assets to be able to live off tax-free investments the way Mrs. Kerry can. The super-rich, as opposed to the merely successful, are the ones who are really able to avoid taxes--which, come to think of it, may be why so many billionaires are supporting John Kerry.
As it happens, the IRS has just released its data on individual income tax returns for 2002. And they reinforce our point about average tax rates. Recall that Mrs. Kerry paid an average tax rate of 12.4% on her declared income of $5.07 million. In 2002, even after the first round of Bush tax cuts, the average rate paid by all taxpayers was still higher than that at 13.03%.
As for the folks in her wealthy neighborhood, in 2002 the top 1% of taxpayers paid an average rate (also known as the effective tax rate) of 27.25%. By the way, the income threshold for getting into that 1% group was only $285,424, down substantially from 2000 and 2001. And that same top 1% of earners paid 33.7% of all income taxes in 2002. The way to think about these numbers is that, despite the Bush tax cuts that allegedly so favored the rich, the tax code remains highly progressive. And these people kept paying the lion\'s share of all taxes even though their earnings declined amid the recession and stock-market slump.
But back to Mrs. Kerry: Some readers wondered how she could be worth nearly $1 billion (as the Los Angeles Times has estimated) and earn only $5.07 million in 2003. Good question, that. It\'s impossible to tell given that Mrs. Kerry has disclosed only two pages of her 1040 form and declines to explain how her assets are deployed. But we agree with those readers who suggest that much of her wealth must be tied up in trusts and estates that don\'t require a declaration of income. Like many of the super-rich, Mrs. Kerry can afford to hire lawyers and accountants to create these shelters for her and her heirs.
The late, great Wall Street Journal editor Barney Kilgore used to say that the rich don\'t mind high taxes because they already have their money. Mrs. Kerry and her husband are cases in point.
The late, great Wall Street Journal editor Barney Kilgore used to say that the rich don\'t mind high taxes because they already have their money. Mrs. Kerry and her husband are cases in point.
http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=110005782
