Originally posted by Jumpman
Well, unless I\'m mistaken, then this is the suggestions forum where everyone offers their feedback on a suggestion made? I\'m generally against all relatively inactive forums. I would like a music forum, but with the forum size too low I know that\'s just a bad idea. If there was so negative feedback then who could stop all the terribly bad suggestions from coming to be?
I\'m not opposing the idea for a trial period for one, but who\'s it going to hurt to post auto news in Off-Topic?
I have posted reasons why an Automotive forum would have positive benefits for those who use it. My reasons are posted higher up in this thread. Since you don\'t seem to care about automotive threads, I\'m willing to bet that you don\'t want to witness the onslaught of new threads that would be crowding Off Topic, if I started posting them there. I don\'t post them now because I know many people in Off Topic don\'t care about this and would just spam my threads.
You make reference to this being a "bad idea" but you don\'t say WHY. I don\'t understand what harm this could do to the entire forum, or Off Topic in particular. Most of the new threads that are going to reside in the Automotive Forum are NOT being posted now, and the few that are posted quickly get buried under all the other Gman threads that everyone spams in. You suggest it will be a "relatively inactive forum" but how do you know? It\'s never been tried, so you have no idea.
I welcome a discusson on the pros and cons of this idea, but you shouldn\'t just vaguely that it\'s a bad idea or a terribly bad suggestion, without supporting your argument.