Originally posted by alliswell
The fact is, Peyton Manning is just as bad as McChoke when it comes to the playoffs. Whats his record? 3-4 in the postseason?
Whats worst, is he bombs in the biggest games. 42-0 to the Jets a couple of years ago in the playoffs. 4 pics vs the Patriots in the NFC championship last year.
I\'ll take Kurt Warner (5-2 all time postseason) when he was at St. Louis anyday over Manning in the postseason. How about him coming back from 20+ down @New Orleans only to have his kick returner muff a punt to destroy all chances of a come behind win. How about coming back from 17-3 in the superbowl to tie it with a rushing TD and a passing TD only to have his defense blow it in the last 2 minutes. If his defense doesnt blow it the game goes to overtime, Warner gets the ball scores and he gets his second superbowl MVP.
Laugh if you want, but I\'m sure people would take Tom Brady etc over Peyton in the playoffs.
Originally posted by Shockwaves
And yeah, I\'d take this year\'s Manning over Warner at any point in his career in a heart beat.
Playoff QBs : Warner, Brady, Montana, Aikman, Bradshaw
Non-Playoff QBs: Marino, P. Manning, Kelly, McNabb, Bulger
I knew the Colts wouldnt win, but I expected it to be close. Once again Manning proves he cant perform when it matters. This is worst then that 40-0 thrashing he took a few years ago. At least then people werent praising him as the best QB ever. Because of that game, the only thing we will remember about Manning this year in the future is that he threw 49 TDs when they changed (enforced if you will) the illegal contact rule.