xbox 360 vs ps3 graphically...

I\'ve read that gamespot graphics comparsion, how bogus

They criple the PS3 by running it through component/720p instead of HDMI/720p(1080p if available) to \'make it fair\'

A true graphics comparison would be both systems at their max.  You don\'t criple one to get a true comparison

Using rushed,  ported  launch games for comparison is also rediculous

The PS3 cell is complex and takes more time to get the most of then the XBOX 360.  Anyone who  puts any chips into this \'comparision\' is a fool

Example:  I would like to see Madden 08 look better on the 360 with the PS3 version running at 1080p and HDMI.  Not going to happen

The true graphics comparison will be when we are able to stack Final Fantasy 13,  Gran Turismo 5 and Metal Gear Solid 4 against Halo 3 and Gears of War.

yes, and how long have we been waiting for those again? You wait for your precious games while the rest has been playing next gen games for over a year now.
seriously, I used to be a sony nut, but it goes only so far.... I\'m not willing to wait 1 year and three months for a ps3 that has yet to even surpass xbox 360 graphically, while I can enjoy next gen gaming now....

All I keep hearing is how great it is gonna be and it probably is, but enough is enough.

yes, and how long have we been waiting for those again? You wait for your precious games while the rest has been playing next gen games for over a year now.

come on, there is nothing "next gen" beside gears of wars on x360, and its just about a month old now.

[clips]

well one thing that i have noticed of sony\'s games (ps2) compared to (xbox) games...i think the movements of the characters in certain games are more lifelike in the sony games,...alot of the games i\'ve seen on the box look great, but some of the movements just looked mechanical,...while gears of war looks good,..some of the videos i\'ve seen of it, at least the physics of it just looks mechanical with no real smooth movements, on the original xbox, i\'ve seen this with jade\'s empire,...both great looking games with mechanical movements.....games from sony\'s camp that look good and play very smoothly,...the first devil may cry, and god of war....i think sony has the edge when it comes to physics....but this is just my simple observation....even "rise to honor" had great physics and smooth gameplay....they could\'ve ditched the sneaking around levels tho....<-----i know it\'s called another term but my mind  just went blank...i need to get some sleep....

come on, there is nothing "next gen" beside gears of wars on x360, and its just about a month old now.

It\'s kind of true, but I found most of my enjoyment with Xbox 360 on Xbox Live playing games like Texas Hold Em.
 
I loved King Kong, though. And Fight Night Round 3 was a great milestone for boxing games, in my opinion.
 
To each his own, I suppose.

[Viper_Fujax]

come on, there is nothing "next gen" beside gears of wars on x360, and its just about a month old now.

depends how high your expectations are. A lot of people have been like "IF IT DOESNT LOOK LIKE TOY STORY ITS NOT NEXT GEN" expectations. fuck that..nba 2k7, madden needs work (mainly with how players move/react to tackles), burnout looks great, rainbow six looks great, gears of war looks great, theyre all fun games and its only going to look better. When you look at madden 2001 (er whatever rhe first ps2 madden game is) it looks like complete shit compared to madden 2004; and that\'s with a system that can\'t compare to the 360 or ps3.

If most of these people want to fulfill their expectations of what "next gen" is, then they need to cryogenically freeze themselves for the ps4 and xbox 720.

Im not saying to settle with what we have as next gen, but im pretty damn happy with the start of it.

you are saying exactly what I was saying. X360 is just starting to get "next-gen" games. Gear of wars is imho the true 1st next-gen.. everything else are just Xbox "upgrade".  

let me quote Politiepet again

while the rest has been playing next gen games for over a year now.

the next-gen is now, it wasnt a year ago with x360 launch and the averagely better game that what was playable on xbox or ps2

[Viper_Fujax]

you are saying exactly what I was saying. X360 is just starting to get "next-gen" games. Gear of wars is imho the true 1st next-gen.. everything else are just Xbox "upgrade".  

no..i think more than just gears of war is next gen. Granted i got the 360 only a little over a month ago, but nba 2k6, oblivion, ghost recon, and FN3 were easily next gen, and i think they were launch games (or close to it). I can\'t remember what other games came out before..i didnt think i would get a 360 at the time.

madden 06 even looked pretty damn good for a first go..they just made it a horrible, stripped down game to get it by the launch date.

yes, and how long have we been waiting for those again? You wait for your precious games while the rest has been playing next gen games for over a year now.
seriously, I used to be a sony nut, but it goes only so far.... I\'m not willing to wait 1 year and three months for a ps3 that has yet to even surpass xbox 360 graphically, while I can enjoy next gen gaming now....

All I keep hearing is how great it is gonna be and it probably is, but enough is enough.

There are other games coming on it soon anyways. Resistance is already out and Motorstorm is due soon. There should be more as well I cant remember of now

[clips]

well graphics at this point really aren\'t an issue.... i think we had a pretty good run with last gen....(ps2 & xbox)... these boxes were outperforming what you see in arcade....i remember a time when we all used to wish for "arcade perfect graphics and gameplay".......and we are waaay beyond that now.....i think it will seriously come down to A.I. and physics this time around....

[clips]

found more of this comparison at gamespot...it\'s from the forums and it has the videos of the games in question....maybe you cats can add your input as i can\'t watch these at work.....discuss...:fro:


http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25231575&tag=recent_topics;title;2

[Viper_Fujax]

i notice no differences but gamma. Except the boxers look better in ps3.

then again the screen is tiny

[Paul2]

man, those video comparisons really does give me a headache.  Just watched one and I don\'t feel like watching the rest of other games video comparison anymore.  Because the graphic are so close, and the different isn\'t really that big when watch it in motion.

I don\'t even care everybody has their opinon. When I see people arguing over these console it looks really stupid. Both will end up looking the same in the end. You got bad and you got good looking games. Both consoles will be just abou equally graphically.

 Shit Get a Wii then. Nintendo doesn\'t care about graphics

[clips]

^^^tru no doubt...i was just in the mall the other day and saw someone playin\' motorstorm...and honestly, the game looks and plays fantastic, i\'ll say it again, graphics are not an issue this time around, it\'s going to come down to who has the best library of games and great physics and A.I.....