Another Star Wars poll

[Bobs_Hardware]

i know, i just posted another star wars thread, but after seeing all 4 on cable recently again, they are my current flavor of the month to talk about, so i have another question

Who was the most powerful with the force???

i think its kind of a tringle between Vader, Luke and the Emperor...Yoda could have been, but i find it doubtful, or could t even be Leia (sp?)

Luke and Vader both overcome the emperors mind tricks...Luke beats vader...Emperor beats luke, luke beats emperor

ugh, who do you think is the most powerful

well, i voted luke, I think definitely by the end he was the most powerful. Darth Vader was powerful, but as Yoda said, the light side of the force was the more powerful. Yoda WOULD get my vote, but he was too old to really use his force to extent.

Definitely luke, he ascended and became the most powerful of them all

interesting this popped up cos I just came on after watching return of the jedi again, BRILLIANT movie

[Bobs_Hardware]

but the emperor would have killed him if Vader didnt turn to the good side again

Quite true... quite true. I dunno... maybe Luke had a hidden psyche up power within him that would have raged up if the emperor tried. Perhaps the emperor was more powerful... but in the end the general idea of the way it was scripted was to lead you to believe that Luke was the most powerful.... well that\'s the way I perceived it anyway. I still think Obi-Wan or Kwai Gon Jin in their younger days would have slawed them all

[Bobs_Hardware]

i think it may perhaps be luke...emperor did overpower him with his lightning like powers...but Luke overcame his mind tricks, he also converted Vader back to the good side.  I think the emeror was more powerful than Vader (Luke turned vader back, it wasnt vader breaking free of the dark side himself) and then vader

remember, luke was still young, and his training was started late.  there is no way he could have mastered the powers of the force by the time Return of the Jedi took place...alright, in my opinion, its Luke

i think if they had of trained Leia she would have slawed them all  

yeah true, but I still go with Luke. Like you pointed out he started training late, and he didn\'t even complete the training with Yoda fully.... so a lot of it was natural skill. If they trained him hard he\'d slaw them no worries

hahah yeah, Leia was a bit of a machine wasn\'t she, i reckon she take a few heads

it was luke......but hes not as strong as he will be, he still need to learn much in the way of the jedi

YODA!!!  Why is no one voting for Yoda?  Yoda is obviously the most powerful.  Remember, he died of old age because NO ONE COULD KILL HIM!  I\'m hoping we will see Yoda in a lightsaber battle in episodes 2 or 3 because he will WHIP ASS!  You\'ll be changing your tune after that.

hmm, the person with the most force in them i would say has to be Anakin Solo, Han and Leia\'s kid. Hope the kids goes to the dark side too .  

Anakin Skywalker.

Simply. He was born out of midichloreans - he was the propechy, the Force as man. [ reminds me of Christianity - if there would be Jesus Christ on Star Wars universe, it would be Anakin ]

Remember that it was Darth Vader who defeated emperor, and defeated the Dark Side. He, almost hopeless, had the POWER to manipulate force and turn himself to the light side once again... wich is a task impossible to ANYONE else.

well i agree that darth vader is the most powerful

since luke could not handle the emperor yet when vader took him on the emperor could do nothing - making me say he was the most powerful of the three

but i also say yoda - he doesn\'t stand at the top in the Jedi Council for nothing

Yoda was more powerful.
If you read any of the books, later in the series Luke has an epiphony that Yoda was far more powerful than all of them. That the reason Yoda exiled himself to Dagobah was that he had become TO powerful to remain in society.
Thats the same reason that Obi-wan went into seclusion.
He realized that Yoda could have easily defeaten the Emperor, but Luke was the one that HAD to.
Read the books.

[Bobs_Hardware]

Originally posted by Darth Joyda
Anakin Skywalker.

Simply. He was born out of midichloreans - he was the propechy, the Force as man. [ reminds me of Christianity - if there would be Jesus Christ on Star Wars universe, it would be Anakin ]

Remember that it was Darth Vader who defeated emperor, and defeated the Dark Side. He, almost hopeless, had the POWER to manipulate force and turn himself to the light side once again... wich is a task impossible to ANYONE else.

ehh?  Vader only turned back to the light side because of Luke.  It was Luke who brought him back to the good side.  And Luke resisted the emperor, Vader gave in.  How can you say Vader is more powerful when Luke was powerful enough not to join the dark side in the first place.  PLUS, luke defeated Vader.

and i dont interpret Anikin as being the chosen one.  They thought he was the chosen one, but they were mistaken.  Luke was in fact the chosen one.  Luke was the one who would bring balance to the force, and he did.

Faithdies says:
since luke could not handle the emperor yet when vader took him on the emperor could do nothing - making me say he was the most powerful of the three

the emperor was focusing all his power on Luke, he was concentrating far to hard to forsee Vader changing back to the light side.  He was taken by surprise.

and Yoda wasnt the most powerful...if the medicloreans were an indication of how strong the force was with you, you find out in episode one that Anikan had a higher mediclorean count.

Since when has Episode 1 been an argument for anything Star wars. That movie was REWRITTEN to appeal to a larger group who grew up with star wars but dont know anything about it. For example, in Episode 1 C3PO is created by anakin Skywalker. Is it just me or is this a big loophole for the REST OF THE SERIES! Originally, C3PO was created in a factory at the same time and programming as R2D2, and that why they are companions, because they are brothers in robot terms.
Errrr.
Its very annoying.

Originally posted by Faithdies
Since when has Episode 1 been an argument for anything Star wars. That movie was REWRITTEN to appeal to a larger group who grew up with star wars but dont know anything about it. For example, in Episode 1 C3PO is created by anakin Skywalker. Is it just me or is this a big loophole for the REST OF THE SERIES! Originally, C3PO was created in a factory at the same time and programming as R2D2, and that why they are companions, because they are brothers in robot terms.
Errrr.
Its very annoying.

Yeah you\'re right about that whole R2D2-C3PO thing. It just doesn\'t make sense. :sconf: