Well, at least you thought about it.
I was about to use this as an example, but no need now
I stated that the threads were standard and the forum still going through its teething phase purely because of the reasons you listed. The threads become stagnant when people stop discussing. They merely post their thoughts and move on. There is nothing much to discuss. Also the fact that currently people are still starting up debates. However you cant expect this to stop immediately and by completely avoiding the process you were active (non-directly?) could be doing nothing but hampering the process.
(here comes my example anyway) Perhaps you should have tried posting it in discussion only without the underlying "I told you so" tag. I guarantee you people such as L-I-C, Ryu, SonyFan and others who you may respect (Billy Gunn?) would reply with thoughts and allow you to discuss. If not this thread, then the next thread. Or whichever thread piques their interest. If no threads are posted, how can you expect to ever get the discussion you want?
Bleh
Its 5 god damn am now... screw you im off to bed