I really like all three controllers. They all have their strengths and weaknesses (
none of them are perfect!) Even though none of them are perfect though, I can still enjoy playing games with each of them without the faults of the controller getting in the way.
The Xbox has the best Analog sticks, no question about it. Not necessarily the best positioned sticks, but the overall feel is excellent. The L/R triggers are slightly too sensitive in many games (I blame the programmers, not the controller). Like in Soul Caliber or Halo, I\'ll accidentally brush against a trigger, not even pushing it in really, and it will do the move assigned to that trigger. The black and white buttons are still kind of out of place, (for some reason when playing new Xbox games, I always forget that the B/W buttons exist). As stated, the d-pad needs improving (PS2 is king in this category) Oh, and the super long Xbox cords rock. I love the cord break-away feature (Microsoft is teh innovative!!! ?)
The PS2 has 4 shoulder buttons -- something I hope all next gen consoles have. The analog sticks are a bit slippery though (sometimes when I\'m playing FPSs or something, I\'ll start to feel my finger slipping off. So I\'ll reach over with my right thumb and hold the L analog in place while I reposition my left thumb back on the stick.) All of the buttons being analog is great – a feature that should be used in more games. The face and shoulder buttons should protrude a little more to allow more accurate pressure sensitivity.
Gamecube controller, well, it’s not bad. It has some problems like the other two controllers, but it is still a great controller. Nuff said. (this thread is more of an Xbox vs PS2 controller thread anyways.)
For the DS3, I wouldn\'t mind it if they moved the L analog stick to where the d-pad is -- as long as they don\'t put the d-pad in the middle of the controller where the L analog is. Maybe they could just put it directly below the analog, so both are easily accessible...? Watch, Sony will get rid of the d-pad altogether to bury 2d gaming once and for all.
Oh, and LIC, are you serious about the SNES controller being one of the best? If so, you have lost your mind.