I won\'t say that every single qb that sucks as a rookie always sucks, but c\'mon..you can tell which ones dont have it..and orton doesn\'t have it. The ones that always suck are in the majority right now, so the odds are againts him as well.
edit: i guess ill list out my examples instead of just claiming something...
losman, the dolphins many tries, boller, carr, orton, grossman, harrington, jackson, leinart, alex smith. And that\'s the very recent..there\'s probably more but i cant think of them off the top of my head.
The ones that turned out good, were good/showed promise from the beginning. manning, brady, palmer, roethlis..garrard even showed promise as a backup and is working out as a starter..now im just getting lazy but you get my point