silent hill 4 was good imo,..they tried somethin\' new with 1st person view while in your room, and it did create some disturbing atmosphere later in the game when your room becomes invaded by the spirits...only parts of it that seemed kinda weak was the combat, and the hilarious sound effects of the hospital nurses...but make no mistake the atmosphere was still there in the game...and i agree with uni...they have to keep the character kinda helpless...
This may sound kinda weak, but if they could somehow enforce some kind of pre-set animation or set of pre-animated defensive moves like just shoving the creatures aside or picking up whatever is in the immediate area and throwing it at the creatures, maybe that will make the combat feel more real, cause i know in reality, if any of us really went up against any of those creatures,i\'d think we\'d respond by naturally throwing something at it, or shoving it out of our way...