ASB is way better for purists, it\'s slower paced, but really simulates the game of Baseball a lot more accurately. There are a couple of graphical glitches, but nothing that takes away from the playability. Plus the stat posting is much more detailed than TP. ASB just isn\'t as flashy either.
TP is a faster, get-to-the-action game. The announcers are decent, but it just doesn\'t hold my interest as much. Plus, the "Hollywood" home runs are back in this game, and it\'s pretty annoying.
The graphics in both are absolutely gorgeous. The stadiums and player models are a bit better in ASB (imho), but I like how the crowd looks in Triple Play.
If I could only own one of these, it would be ASB. There are, however, a few things in TP that are done better, but not the things that make or break a game.
By the way, there is one HUGE annoyance in TP. One of the crowd sounds is a guy yelling "Hey Brewers, wake up." Kinda cool a couple of times, but he said it over 50 times in one game, sometimes back to back. That got old REAL quick.