I\'d go with Vick, just cause even if he is hurting, Carr is very INT prone.
And as for the Eagles having all the pieces, let me point out to you all the pieces they don\'t have:
1) The running game. There is one RB on this team that can do anything, and that\'s Westbrook. The man has about 180 career carries and 800 career rushing yards. That\'s not a lot of work to go off of. If he flounders or gets hurt, the Eagles offense turns one dimensional REALLY quickly.
2) The passing game. McNabb is overrated. I hate to say it cause I like him, but it\'s true. He had a QB rating under 80 last year. He had only one passing TD a game. That\'s a very low number...3rd to last of all QB\'s that were starters all season. His TD/INT ratio was very high. His sack number sky rocketed from the year before from 28 to 43. That\'s 2nd most among QB\'s, which shows holes not only in his pocket movement, something that wasn\'t a problem earlier in his career, but also in the offensive line.
People point to his bad WR\'s as the reason for all of this. That\'s crap. Brett Favre hasn\'t had good WR\'s for years, look what he\'s done. Same with Tom Brady, Brad Johnson, Jake Plummer, and a bunch of other guys with higher QB ratings. They all had bad WR\'s and did a lot better.
3) The secondary, as already mentioned. They relied on it, and they had 2 Pro Bowl corners. Now they lost both in the same year. No matter what you say, that hurts.
4) The thing no one talks about...this defense really wasn\'t that good. They couldn\'t rush the pass, and got Kearse, sure, but what does Kearse do against the run? Pretty much nothing. And the Eagles run defense last year was pathetic. 22nd in the league, allowing 130 ypg. Nothing was done to improve that.
This team may have a lot of weapons now, but they are just using them to mask more and more holes they are developing.