My brother has it and he had the same reactions (too bad he lives about 1100 miles away!). He and his friends weren\'t that blown away at first, but now, he said "It\'s the best FPS on a console (he\'s an old school TF type), and easily game of the year."
He compared the polish of the game to PGR2. Everything is slick and solid apparently.
The graphics aren\'t as good as riddick at first glance, but riddick isn\'t MP or as huge as H2. He expected the MP graphics to be better, but the SP are "crazy".
He still has some gripes about the map design though.
When I asked about which was his favourite weapon, he couldn\'t give me a firm answer so hopefully there aren\'t the horrible imbalances that plagued Halo.
They\'ve also spent hours blowing shit up and playing with the physics (that are tremendously better this time around apparently).
Gee, I wouldn\'t mind playing this game...sometime.