You didn\'t expect this? I don\'t see how anyone couldn\'t expect this. And you know what, it IS NOT out of line.
Sure, you can play Phantasy Star Online online for free, but there is a big difference between PSO and FFXI.
PSO is basically Diablo, just a set of levels that you can sign on and play through with some buddies. Final Fantasy XI is a persistant world RPG that stays online even when you log-off. It doesn\'t have "levels" like PSO\'s forests, mines, caves and ruins. It has a continuously online world that you enter whenever you play and the thing continues to change even when you\'re offline. This isn\'t true with PSO, they are completely different kinds of online games.
EVERY SINGLE MAJOR PERISTENT WORLD rpg starting with Meridian 69 has had a monthly charge (except for the free beta period on most of them of course). Every last one of them has so why should you expect anything else now? Usually the charge is like $10 or less a month (that was the price for Asheron\'s Call when I was actively playing it). It\'s less than what I pay in gas a month so you know what they can have it so long as the game is fun.
You don\'t see people complaining that Anarchy Online on the PC will have a monthly charge based on the fact that Diable doesn\'t have a monthly charge do you? That same illogical argument is what is used when people cite PSO as a reason FFXI shouldn\'t have a monthly charge.
Also, from what I\'ve read PlayOnline isn\'t an ISP service. It\'s kinda like a separate network that will host all of Square\'s content but it is not an ISP service -- at least that\'s the impression I got.